As I've been preparing to minister in North Africa and the Middle East I have spent much time trying to determine the right way to think about Islam. Can Islam be thought of as a revealed religion like Judaism and Christianity? Or is it best to think of it as a natural religion like Hinduism, Buddhism, or Shintoism? Or should we think of Islam as a Judeo-Christian heresy of some kind?
It seemed to me that, as a Christian, the first of these options must be ruled out even though this is how Islam perceives itself. The revelation Muhammad reported to receive from the angel Gabriel is at odds with the revelation of the biblical writers of both testaments and therefore cannot be accepted by Christians as legitimate. So from a Christian point of view, Islam cannot be perceived as a revealed religion.
Eliminating that view, however, did not solve my dilemma because Islam doesn't fit easily into the mold of a natural religion either. The third option is rather intriguing and I first read about it in a blog posting by Peter Leithart who was commenting on the work of AlainBesancon. For Besancon, Islam does not fit neatly into either of the categories of revealed or natural religion. So he has postulated a third way of viewing Islam as a "natural religion of a revealed God." I need to do more reading and research on this view before I can comment on it at length, but for now I'll just say there is much to think about here.
It is Peter Leithart, though, who I believe has done the best thinking about this so far. Leithart argues that Islam is a religion raised up by God as a mirror of Christendom to show it all its flaws and corruptions. I believe that Leithart is really on to something here. In much the same way that God raised up the enemies of Israel as a mirror of their flaws and failings in order to call them to repentance, God has raised up Islam as a mirror of Christendom to point out her errors and corruptions of faith and practice to call the church to repentance. In this way God has used Islam as a parody, a kind of distorting mirror that exaggerates our flaws and corruptions.
According to Leithart, the flaws or corruptions we should see as we gaze into the mirror of Islam fall into four categories:Christological, ecclesiastical, sacramental, and political.
The first sight we see as we gaze into this mirror is an impoverishedChristology. Islam came into being during a time when the church was in crisis over the nature of Christ and the nature of the Trinity. Much of the church where Islam flourished did not follow the orthodox view of the ecumenical creeds and therefore held to an unorthodox view of Christ and the Trinity. It is possible that Muhammad never heard the orthodox view of either doctrine. Would to God that we could say there has been much improvement in this area, but the opposite is actually the case. Broadly speaking the church's theology and Christology are more impoverished than ever. Looking into the mirror of Islam ought to cause us to conscientiously preach and practice a more TrinitarianChristianity.
The next reflection we see as we gaze into the mirror of Islam is an impoverished view of the church. The church in the time of Muhammad was a deeply divided church into multiple schisms. A party spirit characterized the day. The various sects of Christianity had gone the way of courting political power as a means of gaining power for their particular party. The oppression of the Byzantine church during this time was so great that many Christians felt they were being liberated by the conquering forces of Islam. It seems, though, that the old cliché is right, the more times change, the more things stay the same. The party spirit in Christianity is rampant, and the churches never ending efforts to court the power of the state is as predominant now as it ever was in history. In this case the mirror of Islam is to be seen in contrast. Islam has always seen itself as a nation, a civilization, a people of God in unity. To be sure their are sects of Islam, and it is in reality far from a monolithic religion, but it has always thought of itself with a certain global self-consciousness. The church must abandon its tribalism, and strive for the peace, purity, and unity of the church. We must remember that we are churchmen, ambassadors of the kingdom, and not agents of the state.
The third image in the mirror is an impoverished view of the sacraments. Islam emerged from within a Christian world that was deeply ascetic. Monasticism had become the definition of what it meant to be a disciple. While Islam has in one sense moved away from the most severe monastic practices, it may be best seen through the idea of the fast of Ramadan. Fasting is one of the five pillars of faith for Islam. It's part of who they are as a religion and a people. It is part of their self-identification. Jesus and the disciples, however, came eating and drinking. Biblical Christianity is much more a feasting religion than a fasting religion. Yet for centuries we have worshiped and celebrated the sacraments in an austere way that is not at all unlike a reflection of Ramadan. From this rather severe practice which is supposed to be a marriage banquet one would hardly believe that the bridegroom has actually arrived. In this way Islam is God's instrument to call the church back to a frequent and joyous practice of the Lord's Supper.
The final image in the mirror of Islam is political. Islam has always understood itself as a civilization, a body-politic, a nation. It is not merely a set of beliefs or teachings; it is a part of the world that has been subdued by Allah, for Allah. Faithful Muslims will not be satisfied until the whole world is under Islamic law and Islam has infiltrated every area of life. This reflection, of course, is a rebuke to the kind of Christianity practiced in the west today. We have lost this all-encompassing vision of and all-embracing faith. Christianity is a civilization, a holy nation, a culture, with its own language, customs, and laws. We have a King who has subdued the earth and filled it with a new people, in a new creation. This is the meaning of the resurrection. Only we don't believe it. We do not believe, as Leithart, has said, that it is inevitable. Rather, we think it is impossible. We think it's impossible because we really don't believe the gospel--the power of God to everyone who believes.
Islam is God's rebuke and chastisement. It is God's mirror reflecting our biggest flaws and corruptions. May we gaze into this mirror and see that public enemy number one is not Islam, but a church that has failed in four ways: Christologically, ecclesiastically, sacramentally, and politically.
At Equipping Pastors International we are looking into the mirror of Islam in order to learn of our flaws and corruptions, repent of our sins, and help the body of Christ to have a truer understanding of itself both at home and around the world. It is only then that we will see North Africa and the Middle East return to the glory of it's Christian past. Please join us in this effort.